Page 1 of 1

Nord Grand 2 Key Noise Issue

Posted: 02 Nov 2024, 19:35
by MH282
Hey,

I got my hands on a Nord Grand 2 and I love the Instrument. But i noticed an issue with a "plastic" noise with a G key (the one below middle C). It didnt Sound as soft as the others when releasing fast.

I opened the case and saw that exactly at this Spot there is some plastic holding cables from keybed to the platine. Does anybody else have this issue? Is it a production fault and the plastic thing was mounted at a wrong spot, directly under the counter weight of the key? Each time the key is released fast it touches the plastic and makes a bad sound...Anybody has a suggestion how to Deal with that?

Best regards!

P.S. I saw the same at the Post of the dissambly Guide to the nord grand viewtopic.php?t=19178
So maybe it is an issue with all Grands? Maybe somebody with a Nord Grand or Grand 2 can confirm.

Re: Nord Grand 2 Key Noise Issue

Posted: 02 Nov 2024, 23:07
by Schorsch
I would try to carefully remove the cable holder (it’s adhesive) and re-fix it a bit more away from the keybed?

Re: Nord Grand 2 Key Noise Issue

Posted: 03 Nov 2024, 06:01
by ziozeus
Sorry can't help on this. But out of curiosity, can you confirm that metal counterweights are marked W2? (Should be visible in the opposite side of your photo)

Re: Nord Grand 2 Key Noise Issue

Posted: 03 Nov 2024, 09:51
by MH282
Schorsch wrote: 02 Nov 2024, 23:07 I would try to carefully remove the cable holder (it’s adhesive) and re-fix it a bit more away from the keybed?
Thanks for the idea, i was thinking about it but afraid that i lose warranty if there are other issues and I've "manipulated" the product. I just dampened it with a small strip of felt for now and it's better and almost no difference to the other keys. But i think it's either not a good design from Nord if its happening on all Grands (2) or bad quality control if they didnt notice.
ziozeus wrote: 03 Nov 2024, 06:01 Sorry can't help on this. But out of curiosity, can you confirm that metal counterweights are marked W2? (Should be visible in the opposite side of your photo)
Sorry I already assembled the instrument again. What would it mean if they are marked with W2? Maybe i can have a look if I do decide to change the position of the cable holder.

Re: Nord Grand 2 Key Noise Issue

Posted: 03 Nov 2024, 23:51
by ziozeus
Kawai RH3 graded action has 4 levels of weights.
W1 W2 W3 W4, being 4 the lightest.
Nord grand 1 is not graded and uses W3 all across the 88 notes.
From what I get from reviews, Nord grand 2 has a havier acrion but again not graded.
I'm curious to have a confirmation that NG2 uses W2 keys (or maybe a combination of W2 and W3?).

Re: Nord Grand 2 Key Noise Issue

Posted: 04 Nov 2024, 19:12
by M_a_c
I got this "effect" at my workbench on a Studiologic NUMA-X-73 too, where the "cable-holder" was installed in the Hammer-Way also and causing some noise. Interesting that this happens to be the same keybed manufacturer...

Re: Nord Grand 2 Key Noise Issue

Posted: 05 Nov 2024, 01:10
by MH282
M_a_c wrote: 04 Nov 2024, 19:12 I got this "effect" at my workbench on a Studiologic NUMA-X-73 too, where the "cable-holder" was installed in the Hammer-Way also and causing some noise. Interesting that this happens to be the same keybed manufacturer...
In the Nord the keybed is a modified Kawai Version bjt i guess the decision for the positioning of the cable holder is from Nord. Could you fix it for your Instrument and how?

Re: Nord Grand 2 Key Noise Issue

Posted: 05 Nov 2024, 08:58
by M_a_c
In the Nord the keybed is a modified Kawai Version...
Ah... Yes... You´re right... Mea culpa... We´re about the Nord Grand... I just got the NSxCompact in mind... Sorry...
:angel:

Re: Nord Grand 2 Key Noise Issue

Posted: 11 Nov 2024, 23:16
by MaybeANord
:arrow:
MH282 wrote: 03 Nov 2024, 09:51
Thanks for the idea, i was thinking about it but afraid that i lose warranty if there are other issues and I've "manipulated" the product. I just dampened it with a small strip of felt for now and it's better and almost no difference to the other keys. But i think it's either not a good design from Nord if its happening on all Grands (2) or bad quality control if they didnt notice.
This is something I’ve noticed on my Grand 2, but at F above middle C…

Edit: this reminds me, there are two revisions. I have a Rev B. Is yours Rev A or B? I suppose it is possible there was an internal redesign resulting in a different position for these components.

Edit 2: I think I am mixing up the Rev with the Piano 5. I definitely hear this rubbing sound at F though.